Is an off-airport car hire desk always cheaper?
No. At 8 of 29 airports in our November sweep the in-terminal brands were cheaper than the rest, including Paris CDG, Amsterdam, Mexico City and Lima. Check your own airport.
Articles
Does an in-terminal car hire desk cost more?
Usually, yes. Across 38 airports the typical in-terminal brand priced 6% above its airport's market rate and the typical shuttle-bus brand 28% below. What that means if you're hiring, and if you're setting the rates.
By the DayRunner team ·
Usually, yes. Across 38 airports, the typical in-terminal car hire brand priced 6% above its airport's market rate. The typical shuttle-bus brand priced 28% below. That's a gap of about a third of the market rate, for the same car type on the same pick-up day.
It doesn't hold everywhere though. At 8 of the 29 airports with both kinds of desk, the in-terminal brands were the cheaper ones.
These numbers are from one Rate Pulse sweep of public rentalcars.com prices on 10 Nov 2026, for 3-day hires picked up 11 to 24 Nov 2026.
How each desk type priced
Every brand with 10 or more offers, grouped by the desk type the booking site lists. A price position of 1.00 means level with the airport's market rate for the same car type and pick-up day.
| Desk type | Brand listings | Typical price position | Typical rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| In the terminal | 186 | 1.06 (6% over) | 8.1 |
| Car rental centre | 65 | 1.01 | 7.8 |
| Downtown | 32 | 1.01 | 8.3 |
| Shuttle bus | 161 | 0.72 (28% under) | 7.8 |
Ratings are the median for brands with 50 or more reviews. A brand at several airports counts once per airport. Meet-and-greet, train station and outside-terminal desks had too few listings to read much into.
Car rental centres sit level with the market. They're often a short train or bus ride, but the big brands tend to be there, so their prices look like the terminal's.
Where the gap is biggest
The gap below is the typical in-terminal brand's price position minus the typical brand at every other desk type, in percentage points of the market rate.
- Palma de Mallorca: in-terminal 62 points dearer.
- Faro: 58 points.
- Brisbane: 53 points.
- Lisbon: 51 points.
- Christchurch: 49 points.
- Auckland: 35 points. Queenstown: 32 points.
At the other end, in-terminal brands were the cheaper option at Lima (68 points), Mexico City (47), Amsterdam (39), Rio de Janeiro (21), Paris CDG (15), Bangkok (12), São Paulo (11) and Cancún (9). Bogotá was level.
The big gaps are at leisure airports with lots of brands, many of them small shuttle operators: Palma had 18 brands, Faro 23, Lisbon 24. Where the terminal was cheaper, there were only one to five brands off it, and they were mostly downtown offices, car rental centres, a train station desk or a meet-and-greet service. There were no cheap shuttle brands pulling that side down.
If you're hiring a car
- At most airports a shuttle-bus desk saves money. The median shuttle depot in this sweep was 1.8 km away, so the bus ride is short, but allow time for it on the way back, especially for an early flight.
- Look at the rating as well as the price. Shuttle brands rated a little lower on average (7.8 against 8.1), but plenty were rated above 9. At Christchurch one shuttle brand rated 9.4 from 1,715 reviews priced 46% under the market.
- Don't assume. At Paris CDG and Amsterdam the terminal desks were the cheaper ones this fortnight.
If you run a rental fleet
Your desk is part of your price. A customer comparing you with a brand across the road is weighing the walk, the bus and the wait as well as the daily rate.
- If you're in the terminal, the market expects you to sit a bit over the middle. At most airports here the typical in-terminal brand did. If you're pricing under the shuttle brands, ask what that's buying you. You may be giving away the convenience for nothing.
- If you're on a shuttle, your competitive set is probably the other shuttle brands, not the big names in the terminal. Benchmark against them first.
- If your rating is high, test a smaller discount. A shuttle brand rated 9 or more is competing on more than price.
How we got these numbers
- One sweep of public rentalcars.com search results on 10 Nov 2026, searched from New Zealand, at each city's main airport. 3-day hires, picked up on each of 14 days, 11 to 24 Nov 2026.
- Each brand's price position is the median, across car types and pick-up days, of its median daily rate divided by the airport's market median for that car type and day.
- Desk type and distance are as the booking site lists them for each brand's main depot.
- Brands with fewer than 10 offers are left out. Airport gaps only where both in-terminal and other desks appear: 29 of 38 airports.
- Advertised prices, not what customers paid. One booking site, searched from New Zealand. Full method: how Rate Pulse works.
The full airport ranking for the same fortnight is in the airport car hire price index for November 2026.
Questions
Are shuttle-bus car hire brands rated worse?
A little. Brands with 50 or more reviews had a median rating of 7.8 out of 10 for shuttle-bus desks and 8.1 for in-terminal desks. At Christchurch, two shuttle brands with hundreds of reviews each were rated 9.4 or higher.
How far away are shuttle-bus depots?
The median shuttle-bus depot in our sweep was listed 1.8 km from the airport. Allow extra time at both ends for the bus.
What's a market rate index?
A brand's price divided by the middle price at its airport, for the same car type and pick-up day. 1.00 is level with the market, 1.10 is 10% over. See the glossary entry.
See what your market is charging.
Free. Open your city and leave your email to unlock the benchmark and every brand's ratings.